Overview

The Fifth Precinct held its November community meeting to review local crime and enforcement trends, share outreach updates, and raise concerns about safety and police-community engagement.

Introductions

  • Captain Joseph Carollo opened the meeting and introduced members of the precinct staff. He also provided the monthly statistics and coordinated the meeting filling in for Inspector Doherty.
  • Deputy Inspector Robert Kaufman introduced himself as the new executive officer replacing DI Foley. He described his 30 plus years of experience in several areas of the PD and now returned to the Fifth Precinct.
  • Officer Blanco was introduced as a Spanish-speaking resource.
  • Also in attendance was Sergeant Booras, PO Coyle and members of the SC Auxiliary PD.

Crime And Safety

  • The precinct reported zero robberies and one burglary in the prior 28 days; year-to-date figures were 14 robberies and 11 burglaries. Larcenies were down, while vehicle theft prevention remained a concern. Larcenies down for 2026 about 55%. Larcenies last 18 days down 92%. Shoplifting is prevalent.
  • Officers urged residents not to leave cars running while unattended and to remove keys and key fobs from vehicles and avoid leaving valuables and wallets in the car because wallets have personal information which can lead to identity theft.
  • Traffic enforcement reported 97 summonses, including 77 moving violations, or about 79% of the total. Officers emphasized enforcement at high-accident locations and focused on violations that contribute to crashes, such areas were Phyllis Drive, Waverly, Route 27A, Nichols Road, Route 112, Washington Avenue, and Miller Road.

Outreach / Safety / Engagement

  • Officer Coyne discussed several of the past and upcoming events to engage the community. Upcoming events included a precinct tree and menorah lighting, on Dec 2, a Thanksgiving giveaway at the Cornerstone Christian Cultural Center on Nov 21 and a coat drive at St Paul’s church on Dec 6
  • Giveaways for the kids include coloring books and stickers. or arrange for churches or other places to see police vehicles and fire trucks. Its a great way to get young people in the community to speak to an officer. We are looking to expand to the older kids especially when there’s a situation that’s not unpleasant.
  • A lengthy discussion was held concerning drug activity, public behavior, safety near local businesses, train stations, and congregating in parks, which should not be allowed. Officers said they have conducted enforcement at the park after dusk and offered housing, medical, and family-service support, though some people declined services. Residents disagreed about whether people experiencing homelessness should be removed from public spaces; others emphasized that enforcement must comply with the law and that park rules apply after dusk. One speaker who admitted to his past criminal history, stressed that officers should be able to remove people loitering in places especially if late at night because chances are they are up to no good. He added that this is not a good environment for our children to experience and even see harm to people and property. A speaker commented that as a Bellport resident it is not safe to walk here where places like Sayville and Oakdale are. Business owners said people gathering near storefronts and in parking areas are affecting customers and commerce.
  • Residents said fear remains high after shootings and killings at the train station and in the park, and they worry that pushing people out of the park could just move drug activity, fights, stabbings, or shootings to nearby places like 7-Eleven and surrounding areas. They said a police community substation could offer a visible, accessible place for ongoing conversation and relationship-building with police to reduce fear and improve communication, but that it would not solve the underlying problems without broader community engagement. PD officials said the substation suggestion would be shared with the commanding officer.
  • Residents stated that people are still afraid of officers. PO Coyne addressed this by saying we are increasing our engagement with the community and will always reach out when asked.
  • It was stressed that besides a substation, the community residences need to work more together to alert the PD and our legislature of such issues. There’s a need to change the mindset of the people and not to be afraid of the PD; needs to be open dialogue. It was suggested that the Bellport Alliance, BHEP, sponsor a community meeting. Apparently the Alliance holds meetings but the turnout is minimal.
  • One resident alleged ongoing police harassment and requested an opportunity to share evidence; an officer offered to relay the resident’s contact information to a sergeant for possible follow-up.

Action Items

  • Discuss the community’s request for a police substation with the commanding officer and report that the proposal was raised at the meeting.
Share →